CIVIL ESTIMATOR JOB DESCRIPTION
Detailed Civil Estimator job descriptions outlining core duties, required qualifications, and software skills across construction sectors and experience levels.

Civil Estimator Job Description Template
1. About the Role
A Civil Estimator translates raw bid documents into defensible cost positions. Quantity takeoffs, subcontractor solicitation, and bid-day pricing decisions are the weekly core of this work, and getting any of them wrong directly affects whether a project is won at margin or lost to an under-priced competitor. The role occupies a pre-construction seat that touches engineering, procurement, and field operations without formally belonging to any of them. In heavy civil markets, where scopes routinely span earthwork, underground utilities, and substation or transmission infrastructure, the estimator's read on production rates and union labor conditions sets the financial floor for everything that follows.
2. Position Summary
As the Civil Estimator, you develop complete, defensible cost estimates for heavy civil projects ranging from underground utility installation and mass grading to substation and transmission-line construction, ensuring each bid reflects accurate quantity takeoffs, realistic subcontractor pricing, and sound means-and-methods assumptions. You report to the Chief Estimator or Director of Preconstruction and collaborate daily with project managers, field superintendents, and procurement to hand off awarded work with full scope clarity.
3. Why Join Us
Career Impact: Sustained exposure to complex public and private infrastructure bids, including utility-scale solar civil, water treatment facilities, and high-voltage substations, builds the estimating résumé that opens doors to Chief Estimator and Preconstruction Director tracks.
Business Impact: The margin a project earns is largely determined before a shovel breaks ground, making accurate civil estimating the single most consequential input to a heavy contractor's profitability.
Growth Opportunity: Experience across delivery models - hard bid, design-build, and GMP - combined with working knowledge of alternative construction methods, broadens market value and accelerates advancement to senior or lead estimator roles.
4. Key Responsibilities
- Review bid documents, drawings, and specifications to define scope, identify risk elements, and establish the estimating basis for each pursuit.
- Perform detailed quantity takeoffs across earthwork, underground utilities, concrete foundations, grading, and drainage to build complete cost models.
- Solicit, evaluate, and negotiate subcontractor and vendor quotes, maintaining active relationships to secure competitive pricing on assigned scopes.
- Prepare comprehensive bid proposals including bid forms, qualifications, assumptions, exclusions, and scope-of-work summaries for management review.
- Analyze regional labor rates, equipment productivity, union conditions, and market factors to calibrate estimate inputs for each geographic market.
- Coordinate project hand-off meetings between the pursuit team and project management, ensuring scope, schedule, and contract terms transfer without gaps.
- Monitor public and private bid opportunities, attend pre-bid meetings and site walks, and recommend pursuits to senior estimating leadership.
- Mentor and guide junior estimators and takeoff staff on quantity verification, estimating software workflows, and bid compliance requirements.
5. Required Qualifications
- Bachelor's degree in Civil Engineering, Construction Management, or a related field, or equivalent work experience.
- 5 or more years of civil construction estimating experience, with demonstrated success bidding earthwork, underground utilities, or heavy infrastructure projects.
- Working knowledge of crew composition, equipment utilization, and production rates across multiple heavy civil scopes including grading, excavation, and utility installation.
- Ability to read and interpret construction drawings, topographic surveys, geotechnical reports, and contract specifications independently.
- Experience soliciting and evaluating subcontractor and vendor bids, negotiating scope and pricing, and managing subcontractor relationships through award.
- Proficiency with estimating software platforms used for quantity takeoff and bid assembly in heavy civil environments.
- Strong written and verbal communication skills with the ability to present and defend estimates to senior leadership and clients.
- Ability to travel to project sites for pre-bid walks and site investigations.
6. Preferred Qualifications
- Prior experience on high-voltage projects such as substations, overhead transmission lines, or utility-scale solar civil scopes.
- Familiarity with alternative delivery methods including design-build and GMP contracting, with exposure to value engineering processes.
- Experience in business development activities such as client relationship management, market prospecting, and proposal strategy.
- Exposure to EPC project environments or large capital infrastructure programs with CAPEX budgets exceeding $50 million.
7. Success Metrics & Environment
- Bid-to-award ratio, measuring how frequently submitted estimates convert to contracted work within target margin ranges.
- Estimate-to-actual cost variance on awarded projects, reflecting the accuracy of takeoffs and subcontractor pricing assumptions.
- Bid turnaround time against submission deadlines, tracking consistent on-time delivery of complete proposal packages.
- Subcontractor quote coverage rate per bid, measuring the percentage of scopes with at least two competitive quotes at bid day.
- Change order volume attributable to scope gaps in the original estimate, indicating thoroughness of pre-bid document review.
- Typical tools: Estimating and takeoff platforms (commonly HCSS HeavyBid or B2W); scheduling software (commonly Primavera P6 or MS Project).
8. Compensation & Benefits (US Market Benchmark)
- Base Salary Range: $95,000 to $140,000 annually, depending on seniority and market
- Bonus: Project-based or annual performance bonus, typically 5% to 15% of base
- Equity: Uncommon at this level; profit-sharing offered by some contractors
- Health Benefits: Medical, dental, and vision coverage; employer contribution standard
- PTO: 10 to 20 days annually, plus standard federal holidays
- Common Perks: Vehicle allowance or mileage reimbursement, per diem for travel, continuing education support
Figures are estimates based on general US market benchmarks and may be outdated. Adjust based on location, company size, and seniority level.
9. EEO & Legal
Background checks, including criminal history and, where applicable, drug screening, are a standard condition of employment in heavy civil construction. Work authorization in the United States is required; sponsorship availability varies by employer. Reasonable accommodations for qualified individuals with disabilities are available upon request throughout the application and employment process. All applicants are considered without regard to race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, disability, veteran status, or any other characteristic protected by federal, state, or local law.
Civil Estimator Job Description Examples
1. Civil Estimator (Utility & Infrastructure)
The Civil Estimator owns the full bid lifecycle for civil scopes spanning foundation drilling, substation construction, transmission lines, and utility installation, bringing together subcontractor relationships and compliance oversight to produce winning proposals. Reporting to senior leadership, the role builds and maintains partnerships with local suppliers and subcontractors while ensuring all government reporting, submittals, and payments are completed on time.
Key Responsibilities
- Estimate civil scopes, including foundation drilling, substation construction, transmission lines, utility installation, and excavation.
- Identify new public and private sector bid opportunities.
- Attend pre-bid meetings.
- Lead the bid process and manage multiple deadlines.
- Hire, train, and mentor less experienced estimators as needed.
- Build and maintain relationships with local subcontractors and suppliers.
- Review project specs and ensure requirements are met, including minority utilization and regulations.
- Ensure all paperwork, including submittals, billings, payments to subs, and government reporting, is completed and submitted on time.
Required Qualifications
- Bachelor's degree in Construction Management, Engineering, or related discipline.
- 5 or more years of relevant civil construction estimating experience.
- Prior experience working for a self-performing contractor on utility and infrastructure projects.
- Experience in bidding and winning large construction projects in the utility and infrastructure industry, including high voltage projects such as substations and transmission lines.
- Proficiency with B2W, HCSS, and Hard Dollar.
- Skilled in Microsoft Office Suite, including MS Project and Excel.
- Working knowledge of construction scheduling software.
- Excellent written and verbal communication skills.
- Attention to detail and excellent time management skills.
2. Civil Estimator (Heavy Civil Construction)
Embedded within the construction and project management team, the Civil Estimator delivers cost evaluations, bids, and contract negotiations across heavy civil projects including dirt, concrete, street work, and underground utilities. Working closely with current and potential clients, the role maintains continuous client contact to gauge performance and ensures the project closeout process is completed on every job.
Core Functions
- Plan, direct, and coordinate multiple construction projects.
- Provide cost evaluations, develop bids, negotiate contracts, purchase materials, and design project budgets.
- Represent the company at project meetings, conduct needs assessments, and explain design concerns and cost-effective options.
- Maintain a complete understanding of job contracts and contract documents.
- Manage all submittal approvals, RFIs, and delivery schedules.
- Attend owner and project meetings and maintain continuous client contact to gauge performance and communicate relevant information to the project team.
- Build and maintain strong relationships with current and potential clients.
- Implement and ensure the project closeout process is completed on each job.
Qualifications & Experience
- 2 to 3 years of heavy civil estimating experience in dirt, concrete, street work, and underground utilities.
- Ability to thoroughly understand and follow plans and specifications in the construction of a project.
- Knowledge of construction techniques and ability to derive efficient methods of completing tasks.
- Experience with Microsoft Excel, AutoCAD, Agtec Materials, and Agtec Earthwork preferred.
- Strong problem-solving skills, ability to work independently.
- Flexibility to work weekends when required.
3. Civil Estimator (EPC & Civil Construction)
Reporting to the lead estimator, the Civil Estimator shapes complete estimates for medium-sized projects by analyzing specifications, proposals, and engineering drawings to determine scope, takeoffs, and material quantity requirements. Partnering with clients, vendors, and the estimating team, the role monitors client addenda, supports project hand-off meetings, and ensures final estimates align with schedule and cost goals.
Primary Duties
- Review proposal specifications and drawings, and attend pre-bid meetings to determine scope of work and required contents of estimate.
- Incorporate historical data from purchase orders, subcontracts, and productivity analysis reports into unit and person-hour figures.
- Provide technical input regarding project and contract risks to the lead estimator and review final estimates to ensure alignment with project schedule and cost goals.
- Prepare discipline estimates by calculating complete takeoffs and material quantity requirements from engineering drawings.
- Consult with clients, vendors, and other individuals to formulate estimates and resolve issues.
- Monitor client addenda and advise the estimating team on changes during the estimate period.
- Assist with design review options and recommend best solutions based on cost, engineering quality, or material availability.
- Partner with the estimating team to prepare and conduct project hand-off meetings between pursuit and project management teams.
Skills & Qualifications
- Bachelor's degree in Engineering, Construction Management, or related field.
- 5 or more years of experience in the construction industry with a focus on estimating or cost control, including field experience in earthwork, civil and structural, or underground scope.
- Specialized knowledge of alternative construction delivery methods and required regulatory and safety certifications.
- Advanced knowledge of HCSS Heavy Bid Estimating Software.
- Strong technical writing, communication, and interpersonal skills.
- Excellent time management and prioritization skills with the ability to meet tight bid deadlines.
4. Civil Estimator (Complex EPC Projects)
Sitting at the intersection of estimating leadership and technical engineering, the Civil Estimator leads the development of complete estimates for large, complex EPC jobs while providing guidance to other estimators and assisting in the development of department procedures. Operating across bid preparation, site investigations, and design work, the role consults directly with owners on design, rates, and schedules while keeping current with industry trends in equipment, methods, and procedures.
Duties
- Develop complete estimates for large, complex jobs.
- Review owner plans and specifications to develop a comprehensive understanding of the project and form a plan for actual construction.
- Review all bid and contract documents, including home office legal department opinions.
- Conduct site investigations to identify unusual problems or conditions before forming a plan of operations.
- Perform design work required by the project that is beyond standard estimator scope and handle major technical problems during bid preparation.
- Stay current with industry trends including new equipment, methods, and procedures.
- Prepare special engineering studies or reports required by certain bid items or conditions.
- Consult with owners on problems discovered during bid preparation, including design, rates, and schedules.
Requirements
- Undergraduate or graduate degree in mechanical, electrical, civil, or construction-related technology, or extensive equivalent work experience.
- 5 to 10 years of related estimating experience, including extensive knowledge of complex EPC projects.
- Proficiency in Microsoft Office products including Excel, Word, Outlook, and PowerPoint.
- Strong attention to detail, communication, interpersonal, and leadership skills.
- Ability to perform duties in wide-ranging physical and climatic conditions, including heights and complex site structures.
5. Civil Estimator (Earthwork & Site Grading)
A key member of the estimating team, the Civil Estimator leads earthwork division bids from initial review through subcontractor buyout while tracking budget versus actual costs and maintaining a strong safety culture across multiple projects. Collaborating across project management, procurement, and field operations, the role oversees the earthwork division once projects begin and delivers timely document turnover to support execution teams.
Functions
- Review bid requirements to ensure all project aspects are documented and accounted for.
- Set up and close out estimates.
- Prepare takeoffs and work with the Procurement department to secure vendor pricing.
- Identify, manage, and maintain subcontractor relationships to ensure bids and work are completed on time.
- Track and analyze project budget versus actual costs.
- Turn over bid documents and subcontractor buyout information to the Project Management team in a timely manner.
- Review drawings and specifications with the Project Management team and highlight areas of concern.
- Maintain and promote a strong safety culture and collaborate with management across multiple projects.
Experience & Qualifications
- Bachelor's degree in Civil Engineering or Construction Management preferred.
- Minimum 5 years of civil construction estimating and project management experience, including highway construction, earthwork, underground utilities, pile driving, sheeting and shoring systems, and site grading.
- Experience with self-perform work and proven track record of profitability.
- Working knowledge of crew composition, equipment utilization, and production rates for heavy civil construction, including experience negotiating bid terms and conditions.
- Experience with HCSS Construction Software is a plus.
- Superior verbal and written communication skills.
- Excellent organizational skills and attention to detail.
- Ability to handle multiple projects under tight deadlines, adapt to change, and travel locally to project sites.
6. Civil Estimator (Water, Power & Infrastructure)
Accurate, lifecycle-informed cost planning for large infrastructure projects depends on the Civil Estimator, who develops cost plans from concept through detailed design across water treatment plants, substations, overhead power lines, pipelines, and roads. Based within a collaborative estimating environment, the role advises clients on value management and life cycle costing while analyzing labor markets and delivering benchmarking integration across the construction lifecycle.
Accountabilities
- Develop cost plans and estimates from concept through detailed design.
- Support client land acquisitions and site preparation work.
- Deliver and present updated cost plans at appropriate design milestones.
- Review proposed design changes and new technologies and prepare estimates within appropriate accuracy levels.
- Provide commercial input to design optioneering and value engineering exercises.
- Prepare cash commit forecasts for the construction life cycle.
- Collaborate with stakeholders in the preparation of estimates and cost plans.
- Analyze labor markets and cost drivers such as unions and deliver life cycle costing models and benchmarking integration.
Technical Qualifications
- College degree in Construction Management, Civil Engineering, or a related field.
- Minimum 2 to 3 years of experience estimating large-scale infrastructure projects, including Water Treatment Plants, Substations, Overhead Power Lines, Water and Gas Pipelines, and Roads.
- Experience advising clients on value management, value engineering, and life cycle costing.
- Proficient with Microsoft Office, G Suite, AutoCAD, and Navisworks.
- Strong presentation, verbal, written, and communication skills.
- Good organizational and multitasking abilities.
7. Civil Estimator (Utility Solar Construction)
As the Civil Estimator, this role develops civil estimates and scopes of work for large-scale utility solar projects, covering proposal-level designs, RFQ preparation, and subcontractor quote evaluation and selection. The Preconstruction team relies on this work to bridge engineering, purchasing, and electrical project management, with the Civil Estimator reporting to the Director and ensuring gaps in project plans are identified and resolved before subcontract issuance.
Activities
- Collaborate with internal groups including estimating, engineering, purchasing, and electrical project management to bid and execute projects.
- Partner with Field Management and Production to meet project plan objectives.
- Assess preliminary design-build documents to determine civil scope of work required.
- Read and interpret topography, grading, drainage, and erosion control plans and evaluate AHJ drainage requirements.
- Prepare bidding documents and evaluate civil subcontractor quotes.
- Manage scopes of work from initial bid through preliminary design, proposal documents, permitting, AHJ coordination, and subcontract issuance.
- Identify gaps in project plans and implement recovery action plans.
Position Requirements
- High School diploma or GED required; BS in Construction Management or Civil Engineering a plus.
- 3 to 5 years of estimating and project management experience in civil construction.
- Experience with design-build, pricing, equipment management, labor rate derivation, and takeoff management from plans and specs.
- Familiarity with single-axis tracker solar systems and their grading and installation requirements.
- Proficiency in MS Word and Excel.
- Ability to write contract scope of work.
- Willingness to travel to bid walks and job sites as required.
8. Civil Estimator (Demolition & Crushing)
Civil Estimator delivers accurate cost estimates and contract proposals for public and private demolition projects, coordinating quantity takeoffs and assigning labor, equipment, material, and subcontractor costs across multi-state operations. Success in the position means building and maintaining profitable client relationships, finalizing contract terms, and maintaining oversight of contract compliance and change orders from award through project closeout.
Operational Focus
- Identify and develop relationships with strategic targets to generate new demolition business opportunities.
- Identify and evaluate new markets and partnership opportunities through prospecting, networking, and attending industry events.
- Stay current with market conditions, competition, and government initiatives and maintain relationships with existing clients.
- Coordinate quantity takeoffs with assistant estimators and assign labor, equipment, material, and subcontractor costs to formulate accurate cost estimates and contract proposals.
- Engage clients after proposal submission to answer questions and gain feedback on scope and pricing relative to budget or competing proposals.
- Finalize contract terms and conditions, hand off to Project Management and Operations, and maintain oversight of contract compliance and change orders throughout construction.
Knowledge, Skills & Abilities
- Bachelor's degree in Construction Management, Construction Technology, or Engineering preferred.
- 10 to 15 years of public and private estimating experience in demolition, crushing, and screening, with multi-state experience preferred.
- 1 to 3 years of experience training and supervising assistant estimators and takeoff staff.
- Proficiency with estimating software, including HeavyBid and blueprint reading.
- Proven track record of establishing profitable relationships with decision-makers at client organizations.
9. Civil Estimator (Industrial Construction & Maintenance)
The Civil Estimator produces cost estimates and bid proposals for large industrial construction projects while supervising bid preparation for smaller projects and providing technical advice to other estimators. Reporting to the Chief Estimator, the role oversees site visits to analyze soil conditions, evaluates vendor and subcontractor quotes, and trains less experienced estimators to strengthen the department's overall capabilities.
Key Deliverables
- Obtain and analyze historical cost reports and data to prepare cost estimates and bid proposals for large projects.
- Supervise the preparation of cost estimates and bid proposals for smaller projects, including personnel assigned to each project.
- Design estimate summaries and supervise data entry activity.
- Conduct site visits to analyze soil conditions and soil testing and coordinate data exchange with clients, owners, and engineers.
- Calculate total resources required, including direct and indirect costs, and apply appropriate cost values for wage rates, equipment rates, productivity, and market conditions.
- Obtain and evaluate vendor and subcontractor quotes and provide recommendations on selection.
- Submit estimates for formal bid review, oversee bid adjustments per management instruction, and oversee proposal delivery.
- Instruct, train, and develop less experienced estimators.
Professional Experience
- Bachelor's degree in a related field required.
- 5 or more years of scheduling and planning experience on industrial construction or maintenance projects.
- General knowledge of project control principles, including work breakdown structures, cost control, reporting, and variance calculations.
- Proficiency in Microsoft Office Suite, Primavera, SAP, and InEight (previously Hard Dollar).
- Database or Power BI experience a plus.
- Strong communication skills with the ability to interact with customers and craft workers.
- Ability to work additional hours as needed and access all parts of a plant or job site, including heights and confined spaces.
10. Civil Estimator (Underground Utility & Piping)
Embedded within a division focused on piping, excavation, and underground utility construction, the Civil Estimator develops cost-effective estimates covering mechanical and piping underground, sitework, and above-ground mechanical projects while supporting business development efforts. Working closely with clients, vendors, engineers, and internal departments, the role advances value engineering ideas, monitors developer budgets for upcoming opportunities, and travels to local and regional sites to assess construction sequence and site conditions.
Areas of Ownership
- Gather proposals, drawings, specifications, and related documents to prepare work for estimating.
- Perform and confirm quantity takeoffs and identify labor, material, and time requirements.
- Review and confirm quotations from vendors and subcontractors and coordinate with them to develop project estimates and proposals.
- Analyze regional labor rates, per diems, and market conditions to calibrate estimate inputs.
- Consult with clients, vendors, and internal departments to formulate estimates and resolve issues.
- Develop value engineering ideas with engineers, vendors, and subcontractors to drive project design and economics.
- Travel to local and regional project sites to assess construction sequence, site conditions, and perform time studies.
- Support division management in creating new proposals and monitor owner and developer budgets for upcoming bid opportunities.
Background & Experience
- Bachelor's degree in Construction Management, Engineering, Business, or related field preferred, with equivalent work experience accepted.
- Minimum 5 years of estimating experience focused on piping, underground utility work, and civil construction.
- Knowledge of estimating fundamentals, typical piping and civil activity costs, and Fixed Price, Time and Materials, and Unit contract pricing mechanisms.
- Familiarity with scheduling software such as MS Project and proficiency in MS Office applications and estimating software.
- Strong mathematical aptitude with ability to analyze and interpret complex information and make sound judgments.
- Excellent organizational, planning, and time management skills with ability to prioritize multiple tasks concurrently.
- Strong written and verbal communication skills with the ability to compose technical documents and deliver presentations to stakeholders.
- Self-motivated and driven problem solver who can work both independently and as a collaborative team member.
11. Civil Estimator (Site Utility & Grading)
Reporting to the Lead Estimator, the Civil Estimator produces comprehensive bid proposals and detailed quantity takeoffs for site utility and grading projects, overseeing prequalification requirements, internal bid reviews, and project hand-off meetings with field management. Partnering with architects, consultants, vendors, and owners, the role maintains relationships throughout project execution and ensures all bid documents, insurance forms, and contractual qualifications are prepared and submitted accurately.
Role Responsibilities
- Review public notices to identify bid opportunities and forward to the Lead Estimator for evaluation.
- Review all bidding documents thoroughly, assess risk elements, and prepare and maintain bid plans and document control.
- Perform detailed and annotated quantity takeoffs to build complete estimates.
- Review project documents for cost effectiveness and identify value alternative opportunities.
- Prepare qualifications, assumptions, and exclusions aligned with contractual requirements and oversee all prequalification requirements, including RFQs and RFPs.
- Communicate with architects and consultants to clarify scope, materials, and schedule requirements.
- Prepare comprehensive bid proposals including bid forms, insurance forms, and all required documents and participate in internal bid reviews.
- Lead project hand-off meetings with field management, support the PM team during project execution, and maintain relationships with vendors, owners, and subcontractors.
Minimum Qualifications
- Bachelor's degree required.
- 5 or more years of equivalent experience in estimating site utility and grading work.
- General knowledge of construction principles, negotiated bids, hard bids, and GMP processes.
- Ability to read and interpret drawings and specifications.
- Working knowledge of estimating tools, including HCSS HeavyBid, HardDollar, B2W, AccuBid, AgTek, BlueBeam, PlanSwift, On-Screen Takeoff, Trimble Business Center, and Primavera P6.
- A value-added approach to estimating.
- Solid interpersonal and communication skills.
12. Senior Civil Estimator (EPC Cost Estimating)
Sitting at the intersection of commercial strategy and technical cost management, the Senior Civil Estimator manages the development of estimates from inception through completion, consolidating components into CAPEX cost volumes while assessing risk, escalation, and market pricing across global EPC projects. Operating across proposal cash flow models, bid evaluations, and working capital analyses, the role presents estimate review packages to business line management and converts approved estimates into actionable project budgets for the execution team.
Job Functions
- Manage the development of estimates from inception to completion and consolidate components into CAPEX cost volumes and bid forms.
- Review and ensure the quality and integrity of estimates and incorporate lessons learned.
- Prepare basis and assumption documentation and establish conceptual scopes when full definition is not available.
- Support bid evaluation of cost and schedule criteria and prepare bid evaluations.
- Prepare non-manual and indirect cost estimates covering temporary facilities, construction tools and equipment, staffing, startup services, and other field costs.
- Present estimate management review packages to team, department, and business line management.
- Prepare proposal cash flow models and working capital analyses.
- Perform escalation calculations, assess uncertainties in productivity and pricing, prepare cost studies using historical data, and identify risk mitigation strategies.
- Convert estimates into project budgets, communicate assumptions to the execution team, and analyze cost and price data from suppliers and subcontractors.
Education & Experience
- Extensive experience in EPC estimating practices.
- In-depth knowledge of project schedules, cost index and escalation projections, and engineering, procurement, and construction methods.
- Knowledge of global market pricing, construction practices, risk management, and commercial influences, including insurance, taxes, and charging practices.
- Proficiency in Microsoft Office applications and estimating platforms, including HCSS and Candy.
- Proficiency in Lump Sum and Design Build estimates for competitive bid projects.
- Skilled in oral and written communication with demonstrated ability to present estimating information to peers and management.
- Demonstrated ability to organize, direct, perform, review, and present cost estimating products with minimal supervision.
Editorial Process and Content Quality
This content is developed by the Lamwork Editorial Team using structured analysis of real-world job data, skill requirements, and hiring patterns.
Research framework by Lam Nguyen, Founder & Editorial Lead.
Reviewed by Thanh Huyen, Managing Editor.
Learn more about our editorial standards.